El Paso: City hits back at Trump
People walking over the Paso del Norte Bridge linking this West Texas border city to Mexico can watch US President Donald Trump’s border wall getting bigger in real time.
Workers in fluorescent smocks can be seen digging trenches, pouring concrete and erecting rust-coloured slabs of 5.5-metre-high metal to replace layers of barbed wire-topped fencing along the mud-coloured Rio Grande, which is usually little more than a trickle.
Most of the more than 70,000 people who legally cross four city bridges daily — to shop, go to school and work — pay the construction in the heart of downtown no mind. But on a recent weekday, one man stopped and pointed, saying simply “Trump”. In his State of the Union address, the President said a “powerful barrier” had cut crime rates in El Paso. He’s holding a rally here on Monday to show why he’s demanding more than 100 kilometres of new walls, costing $5.7 billion, along the 3000-kilometre border, despite opposition from Democrats and some Republicans in Congress.
But many in this city of dusty desert winds and blistering salsa bristle at the prospect of their home becoming a border wall poster child.
Mr Trump said barriers turned El Paso from one of the nation’s most dangerous cities to one of its safest, but that’s not true. El Paso, population around 800,000, had a murder rate less than half the national average in 2005, a year before the most recent expansion of its border fence. That’s despite being just across the border from drug violence-plagued Ciudad Juárez, Mexico. Many residents say El Paso embodies a cross-border spirit that transcends walls rather than proving more are needed.
“The richest of the rich, the poorest of the poor, we all have different reasons for wanting to cross, and people cross every day,” said El Paso City Council member Peter Svarzbein.
El Paso lays bare the mixed feelings the border inspires. Even native Beto O’Rourke, a former Democratic congressman now mulling a presidential run, says barriers are inevitable but the President's calls for an expanded wall are the “cynical rhetoric of war, of invasions, of fear.”
O’Rourke will help lead a Monday evening march opposing the wall with dozens of local civic, human rights and Hispanic groups at the same time Mr Trump is holding his rally. Organisers expect thousands to turn out.
“While some try to stoke fear and paranoia, to spread lies and a false narrative about the US-Mexico border and to demand a 3000-kilometre wall along it at a time of record safety and security, El Paso will come together for a march and celebration that highlights the truth,” the former congressman said in a statement. For centuries, virtually nothing but an often easily wadable Rio Grande stood between the city and Juarez. But worsening economic problems in Mexico increased the flow of immigrants into the United States in the 1970s, prompting Congress to approved chain-link fencing here and in San Diego dubbed the “Tortilla Curtain”. More barriers were added in the 1990s and 2006.
Public reaction to the security measures initially was positive in some quarters because it helped reduce vagrancy and petty crime. But many residents now complain MrTrump’s demands have gone too far, making their home sound like a war zone and offending both them and people from Mexico.
“The border is fluid culturally, economically,” said Cesar Blanco, a Democratic politician who lives a stone’s throw from the wall. “We are a binational community.” Those who live near the wall say they see few people climbing the barriers now. In fiscal year 2017, about 25,000 people were apprehended in Border Patrol’s El Paso sector, down from 122,000-plus in fiscal year 2006.
Instead, those crossing illegally now tend to do so outside the city in desolate deserts where deaths from exposure have risen. Democrats argue electronic sensors and patrols are a more effective answer for additional border security. The demand for more and bigger walls has become “the supreme symbol of racism”, said Fernando Garcia, executive director of the Border Network for Human Rights in El Paso. “Obviously he’ll have some people attend his rally,” he said of the President, but “he cannot lie about what we’re about.” Many Republicans, though, insist the low crime rate here is not a coincidence. “There are regular shootouts near the border, dangerous narcotics trafficked,” said recently-elected Republican Congressman Chip Roy, who represents a district between Austin and San Antonio. “The good news is that we can stop this,” Congressman Roy said in a post-State of the Union fundraising email championing a Mr Trump-backed wall.
The FBI’s Uniform Crime Report shows El Paso’s annual number of reported violent crimes dropped from nearly 5000 in 1995 to around 2700 in 2016. But that corresponded to similar declines in violent crime nationwide and included times when the city’s crime rates actually increased year over year despite new fencing and walls.
The towering barriers don’t stop Juarez from almost seeming like another neighbourhood in El Paso. From many places, you can see white city buses rumbling on the other side of the border and read green street signs marking that city’s major thoroughfares in Spanish. Buildings more than a few stories tall in El Paso have sweeping views of downtown Juarez.
Mickie Subia’s single-storey home in the historic, downtown Chihuahuita neighbourhood is steps from the barrier, providing glimpses of Mexico through fencing and metal slats. She said the wall didn’t make her feel safer. “We don’t have a problem with Border Patrol,” Subia said.
“We don’t have a problem with anyone coming from over there, either.” Dee Margo, El Paso’s mayor and a former Republican state politician, tweeted after the State of the Union his city was “NEVER one of the MOST dangerous cities in the U.S.”, adding border walls are only partly the reason. “I’m really glad President Trump is coming here,” he said in a subsequent interview. “I just hope we get the chance to show him what it’s really like on the border.”
Originally published as ‘Fears and lies’: City hits back at Trump